Honest Mistake or Fraud: Guessing Clinton Aldrich’s Age
Allegations of voter fraud in Southwick, Massachusetts, had residents questioning the integrity of the voting process following the arrest of Clinton Aldrich, who was charged with illegal voting on Election Day, 1868. The case attracted considerable interest throughout the region. Aldrich appeared in the afternoon session of Westfield Police Court on Saturday, November 14, 1868, with Judge M. B. Whitney presiding. Massachusetts State Senator Henry William Fuller was counsel for the defense, while H. B. Stevens represented the Commonwealth. Henry William Fuller, circa 1868 Southwick Selectman Aurelius Moore was called as a witness on behalf of the Commonwealth. Under direct questioning, he testified that he saw the young Aldrich place a piece of paper into the ballot box, but he was not sure what, if anything, was on it. Upon being recalled, Moore testified that when he counted all the ballots, each was filled in for either Republican or Democrat, and that there were ...